Monday, 8 May 2017

Ban on advertising of dental practices contrary to EU (not consumer) law - CJEU in Vanderborght (C-339/15)

It is not the first time that the CJEU has to assess the compliance with EU law of Belgian law and its tendency to absolutely prohibit certain commercial practices. In the Vanderborght case (decided last Thursday, 4 May; case C-339/15), it was the ban on advertising of dental practices that was at stake.

Mr Vanderborght offered and advertised his dental services in Belgium, the latter by installing "a sign consisting of three printed faces, stating his name, his designation as a dentist, the address of his website and the telephone number of his practice", as well as by advertising in local newspapers. On his website he provided information on various treatments he offered. A professional association of dentists (Verbond der Vlaamse Tandartsen) was concerned about his advertising practices as pursuant to Belgium law advertising relating to oral and dental care is prohibited, in order to protect public health and dignity of the profession of dentist. Mr Vanderborght claimed that such a general ban on advertising was contrary to EU law, among other things, to the provisions of the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (2005/29/EC).

The CJEU points out that the UCPD allows the Member States to introduce other rules that aim at protecting health and safety of consumer products, as well as codes of conduct related to upholding "high standards of integrity on the part of the professional" (para. 26-27). Therefore, EU consumer law will not stand in the way of imposing a general ban on advertising regulated services, which ban is motivated by concern for public health and safety of products. However, such a general ban on advertising may infringe the freedom of movement of services - art. 56TFEU and provisions of the E-Commerce Directive (2000/31/EC), considering also advertising via websites falls within the scope of this ban.


  1. Dental specialists suggest that you complete a teeth cleaning professionally twice every year. An occasional cleaning includes the evacuation of dental plaque and tartar with a specific end goal to avoid cavities, gingivitis and gum ailment. Anaheim Dental Work

  2. We offer a genuine loan to people who are sincerely and honestly in need of some money for some personal and business purposes. We are glad to be able to fulfill your dreams in offering you the exact amount of money you need. we do not charge for processing/origination cost. our money is secured and safe and it will be delivered into your bank account within 24 hours of application. contact us now with your interest. Email: